There will be a momentous decision being made in Scotland on Thursday 18th April 2014, whether to become independent of England or stay within the union.

I received a phone call from an official referendum polling organisation last Saturday,(13th September) the first ever such call I have received. Was I a random number being called- I shall never know. The caller did not get my salespersons treatment, he was too polite and did ask if it was a good time to call for answering a few questions. End of story…It was not a good time to call.

Votes will be placed, I believe, mainly with heart or head. Some people will vote with both. We have had only one Member Of the Scottish Parliament (MSP) give our remote area the time of day, a socialist who supports the ongoing union of Scotland. I note that The First Minister Alec Salmond says he and his party have covered every area in Scotland. He should define what that means! Even the sitting Scottish Nationalist Party member, (SNP) has not ventured to arrange any local meetings. Is that confidence because he was voted in as an MSP last time, or is there something else going on?

On the other hand, those who represent staying in the union, (‘No’ to independence) have not tried to kid anyone that they have travelled far and wide in number to promote their cause. (One of their number has genuinely tried to). How do you interpret this?

The ‘Yes’ campaign has been vigorous. Its momentum has excited a lot of people. Throughout, the independence campaign has had the advantage of being blessed with a positive sounding ‘Yes’. The ‘No’ campaign has been very slow to react and speed up, they have been seen as lazy; the pro-union campaign has been disadvantaged throughout with the negative sounding ‘No’. They have been struggling to find a way to make their message vibrant.

Scottish Police have begun patrolling armed, without any public debate or agreement to it. There has been an attempt to slip this through under the cover of the Independence Referendum. The Minister For Justice tried to fob off public protest, saying it is solely a police matter: it is not. The SNP Minister has responsibility for police and policing matters. After local government and public protests, reports are being called for. The reporting organisations do not sound like bodies independent from the Police they will be reporting on.

Questions: why is the Scottish Government arming police? what are they intending?

All sides have indulged in disingenuity to suit their causes, some apparently more than others; the SNP were caught out very early on in this long campaign. As a cynic, I have to sadly admit that is the way of politics. One of the prerequisites of being a politician anywhere, is being able to look someone in the eye, appear to be sincere while acting out the events of The Ides Of March. That said, it is fundamental to ongoing well-being in Scottish politics and in Scottish community life that there is respect on all sides whatever the outcome of the vote.

There are many unanswerable questions for which, political imagination has been required to field them. There are answerable questions which have been either glossed over, dismissed as scare-mongering, or side-stepped. Time scales for change, if it is a ‘yes’ vote, are, in my view over-optimistic. Is the Scottish government canny enough and strong enough to handle experienced, tough and clever negotiators in or from London, because there is no doubt,they will be wheeled out. A similar question can be asked if there is a ‘No’ vote. After the Edinburgh Tram contracts debacle, I wonder.

If it is a vote to keep the union, a great deal of trust will have been handed to Westminster, which on past form has been totally untrustworthy. Will this and future Westminster Governments honour what they have promised, the equivalent of Devo Max which, if you remember, was not allowed to be an option to vote for? (Maximum Devolution for which there is no given definition). Will they honour the tenets of the Edinburgh agreement which agreed the upcoming Referendum? I believe, a great deal of redefining and fiddling of definitions, is likely to occur. I would like to be proved wrong. A close vote should and ought to focus ruling classes both in London and Scotland.



  1. I like this analysis. Of course it’s a big deal, and a great many people are interested to see what will happen. For my part I shall be happy when the wall-to-wall coverage lets in some chinks of light with news from elsewhere.

  2. Hi Gilly,

    We were discussing relief from wall-to-wall this evening coverage of the Referendum. Whatever the outcome, there will be yet more with a variety of other foci.


  3. Oui. Beaucoup de questions. Quand je parlais de “vos voisins” je parlais de nous, Français, qui avons vu notre vote “NON” de 2005 au référendum a été jeté à la poubelle par Sarko qui a signé le traité de Lisbonne contre la volonté populaire.

    Je parlais d’espoir, car nous aimerions que pour une fois le résultat d’un référendum soit respecté, car nous, nous vivons sous une “tyrannie élue”, alors que le monde entier croit que nous sommes une démocratie…

  4. Les politiques et les democraties ci sont tres compliquee. J”attendre avec beaucoup d’interesse que’ce qu’ils faisont maintenant nos representatives en Westminster avec leur promises. Ils on lui jete dans un poubelle en 1979. Donc il y a un histoire de pauvre confiance. Il n ya pas pour confiance la majorite vote etait “non” Ci son autres raisons pour la vote. 45% disaient ‘oui’. La prochaine fois, et biens sur il sera une autre fois, je pense ils aura succes, si il n y a pas des grandes changes, changements acceptable et equitable avec la situation politiques en Ecosse.

Thanks for visiting me. Please share your thoughts and ideas. Comment here.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s